Follow us on:
Carnival Games Mini Golf Review
5 out of 15
It don't mean a thing if it ain't got that swing.
Date: Wednesday, October 29, 2008
Author: Brandon "Dynamite Golf" Cackowski-Schnell

Well, that's not entirely true. If you score well enough on a hole you get a puzzle piece, and if you get all three puzzle pieces for a theme, you get a new putter based on that theme, however it's just for looks and doesn't do anything to help your swing. You can also play a round of golf in local multiplayer against three other people, and win all of their tokens from them. Players can use diversions to throw others off their game and score epic loot; however the biggest diversion comes from the swing mechanic.

When swinging, you use the up and down arrows of the d-pad to pick your shot angle, and the left and right arrows to pick your aiming position. Once you have your aim down, you hold down the A button and then swing wildly to increase the power meter, letting go of the A button once you hit the right power level. There's no back swing, and no one to one swing mechanic. In fact, any real precision when it comes to picking the power level is nigh on impossible. You can either somewhat move your arms, and generate barely any power, or swing for the fences so that the game recognizes that you're trying to move the power meter, and end up blasting the ball out of the course. Add to this some funky ball goings on where the game will strangely set your ball in odd places if it gets stuck in a corner and you have one very frustrating experience.

And then there's Barker, your tour guide and sometimes opponent in the game. Barker is the mascot for the Carnival Games line, with his oversized head and old time dress. He's also one of the meanest competitors and worst sport you'll ever go up against. When playing in single player mode, you choose to play a hole solo or play against Barker. If you think that the swing mechanics are frustrating, try flailing your way through a hole against Barker only to see him step up to the tee, hit a precision power shot that you have no hopes of ever making and ultimately getting a hole in one. If that wasn't bad enough, you're then subjected to an animation of Barker attempting to give you a Barker token, just to pull it away at the very end. Stay classy Barker. If the game is targeted at kids, that's a hell of a way to treat a child. If you do win you're treated to sayings like "I got pwned!" which is about a thousand times worse. You also get a Barker token which nets you one four hundredth of a pair of pants.

Even the course layout seems to be designed to cause you as much frustration as possible. There's no ability to string holes together into a proper course, or even play all of the holes within a theme in one round. Once you pick a hole and complete it, you're backed out into the course menu where you have to pick your theme all over again and then pick a hole. When was the last time you bounced around the holes in a mini-golf course with no sense of direction?

The game looks nice, albeit a little GameCube-y, but unfortunately, the pretty pictures and cute animations of the various course contraptions don't help what's really wrong with the game, namely the cruddy swing mechanics. Younger kids will be excited by the courses at first, but once they get a Wiimote in their hand and experience the joy of flailing, coupled with Barker's obnoxious comments, they'll be begging you to put Wii Sports back in the machine. With its lackluster swing mechanics, poor course organization and few rewards, Carnival Games Mini Golf proves yet again that no good can come from carnies.

Questions or comments? We'd love to hear from you .

Drawn to Life: The Next Chapter Review
Give a man a fish and he eats for a day, draw a man a fish gun and he shoots fishes forever.
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Review
Brash, loud, pretty, offensive, and over the top -- Modern Warfare 2 is a smashing success.
Surprisingly decent.
Ever wonder what thoughts ran through Fidel Castro's head during his years in power? Tropico 3 gives you the chance to find out, and do so much more.
Shoot, loot, repeat.
A look at the Dark Elves race being added to the footballer.
To include online multiplayer battles.
Preparing for a number of DLC packs next year.
Happening alongside the Nemesis Confrontation event.
Skate 3 Hands on Preview
Fast becoming the Madden franchise of skating.
Gratuitous Space Battles Preview
You most likely have never heard of Gratuitous Space Battles -- well, it's now time to pay attention.
We get first hand info at PAX from Executive Producer Jeffrey Steefel on what's in store for LOTRO players.
Serious shooting.
There's no question that skydiving from orbit without a parachute isn't something that just anybody can do. But what if you wanted try it while wearing a big sexy piece of powered armor? Section 8's multiplayer beta gave me the chance to repeatedly engage in this adrenaline-pumping experience. and shoot a lot of internet-people full of holes at the same time. Read on to find out what will set this game apart from other knock-offs in this genre.