Follow us on:
Gears of War 2 Review
13 out of 15
Intense action covers up lame writing in this much-improved sequel.
Date: Friday, November 07, 2008
Author: Tracy Erickson

  • Game: Gears of War 2
  • Platform: Xbox 360
  • Publisher: Microsoft Game Studios
  • Developer: Epic Games
  • ESRB: Mature
  • Genre: Inevitable Sequel
  • Players: 1-10


  • What's Hot: Awesome action bolstered by fantastic scenarios; even pacing and fine-tuned difficulty; stellar multiplayer


  • What's Not: Cheesy, sophomoric dialogue; paper-thin story packed with one-dimensional characters



  • We all have our guilty pleasures: the midnight snack, trashy reality shows, bad action flicks. Sometimes you just can’t help yourself. Gears of War 2 is exactly like that, its bad writing excused by delicious action. Don't feel guilty, though, because this is one gaming pleasure that isn't trashy or bad, but will likely have you up well past midnight having loads of fun.

    Picking up months after the events of the original, Gears of War 2 reprises your role as Marcus Fenix in an all-out assault on the Locust hub. The lightmass bomb sent through the tunnels to destroy the Locust failed and now they have reemerged stronger than ever. Jacinto, the last human stronghold, has become the target of new weapon that can sink entire cities. A preemptive strike is called in an effort to defend the city, which prompts the battle worn Delta Squad back to head back underground. Dom, Baird, and Cole return to support Fenix in the mission, as well as a cast of new characters.

    A great deal of effort was invested into crafting a compelling story populated with interesting new characters, yet it still doesn't work. The sequel fares little better than the first with a meandering plot that requires complete dissociation; in other words, don't bother caring about what's going on. You're sent to a handful of locations with little justification, often never getting any validation even after you've run through the level. At various points in the campaign, Fenix and company debate with each other the reasons behind their mission and exactly what it is they're doing. Ironically, they always confess to not knowing. It's a satirical point and one that seems to reflect the writers' inability to explain what is going on within the game.

    Tacky one-liners and cheesy conversations certainly don't convey what's going on aside from banal banter among unlikeable characters. Dizzy, the cowboy hat-toting driver with a Southern drawl takes the cake for worst game character of the year, perfectly embodying the game's poor narrative construction. Rookie Ben Carmine comes in at a close second, playing the stereotypical green recruit that can't see past his own face. All that big talk about a grand, emotional story and dynamic characters never materializes; instead, you get a paper-thin plot tied together with one-dimensional figures.

    The phenomenal action is what makes Gears of War 2 a great game. Forget story, characters, dialogue--here is a game with memorable thrills, tough enemies, and tons of variety. New moves like using an enemy as a living shield expand your options on the battlefield too, also contributing to a greater sense of variety and keeping things fresh. Cool scenarios such as a surprisingly fun escort missile that has you firing turrets against hundreds of drones, Brumaks, and Reavers, and a watery battle against a fish-like beast ratchet up the action. Even the most basic of battles against a squad of drones is exciting thanks to solid AI, brilliant weapons, and good level design.

    Drawn to Life: The Next Chapter Review
    Give a man a fish and he eats for a day, draw a man a fish gun and he shoots fishes forever.
    Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Review
    Brash, loud, pretty, offensive, and over the top -- Modern Warfare 2 is a smashing success.
    Mad Catz offers up a slick new controller that isn't just for Modern Warfare 2 fans.
    Nancy is back with another fun, classic (and modern) adventure.
    This smaller version of LBP is a certified winner.
    A look at the Dark Elves race being added to the footballer.
    To include online multiplayer battles.
    Preparing for a number of DLC packs next year.
    Happening alongside the Nemesis Confrontation event.
    Skate 3 Hands on Preview
    Fast becoming the Madden franchise of skating.
    Gratuitous Space Battles Preview
    You most likely have never heard of Gratuitous Space Battles -- well, it's now time to pay attention.
    New Super Mario Bros Wii blends the old and the new.
    Dragon Age isn’t just one of the more hotly anticipated games of the holiday season—it’s the single most ambitious RPG project you’ve ever seen.
    Same game, new platforms.