I went to the local game store (hint: rhymes with framepop), and picked up Sega's The Club. Wouldn't you think it's tough to go wrong with an FPS by the people who brought you Geometry Wars? I also picked up Lost Odyssey, but I'm not sure why. As one of the resident sports gamers here, usually I only touch RPGs with a 30 foot pole, but the sales clerk sounded like he knew what he was talking about.
I think I'll just go blow some stuff up in the Club for now.